Here’s Exactly What Happens When You Call a Nonprofit Credit Counselor

Image source: Getty Images

A close friend of mine carried a pile of credit card debt for years. He never said a word about it, so I never knew how much he was suffering inside and stressed about money.

Then one day he finally told me things weren’t going so great financially. I was almost embarrassed it took him that long to say something. But I was so glad he did. He confronted his debt head-on, and today he’s absolutely crushing it financially.

His only regret was he wished he’d taken the first step sooner.

If that story sounds a little familiar, this article is for you. Because one of the most underused tools in personal finance is a simple, free phone call to a nonprofit credit counselor.

Nonprofit vs. for-profit credit counseling: What’s the difference?

This is the first thing worth knowing. Not all credit counseling places run the same business model.

Nonprofit credit counselors — like those affiliated with the NFCC (National Foundation for Credit Counseling) or MMI (Money Management International) — are funded by creditors and grants. Their mission is to help you. Initial consultations are typically free, and their advice doesn’t depend on you signing up for anything.

For-profit debt relief companies are a different story. They often charge upfront fees, can be influenced by profit-oriented motives, and generally exist to make money for their owners or shareholders.

The FTC has brought scores of law enforcement actions against bogus credit-related services, and in 2010 amended its Telemarketing Sales Rule to prohibit for-profit debt relief companies from charging fees before they actually settle or reduce a consumer’s debt. If someone cold-calls you offering to “settle your debt for pennies on the dollar,” be very skeptical.

The short version: Nonprofit = free guidance and real options. For-profit = often costly, and sometimes risky.

What to expect on your first call with a counselor

The first call is genuinely low-stakes.

The introduction call lasts 30-60 minutes, depending on your unique situation and what you need to accomplish your goals. Here’s roughly what that looks like:

• A review of your income, monthly expenses, and total debt balances
• A breakdown of your interest rates across each card or loan
• A look at your credit report, if you give permission
• A plain-English explanation of all your options, with no pressure to choose any of them

That last part is probably the most important. You are under zero obligation after this call.

If you hate everything they say, that’s ok! All you’ve lost is an hour of your afternoon.

In my experience covering personal finance, the people who make this call are almost always glad they did. Even if they don’t follow through with a formal plan, just having a clear picture of where things stand tends to lower the anxiety. A lot.

DIY debt payoff vs. a debt management plan

One thing your counselor may bring up is a debt management plan, or DMP. Here’s a quick explainer on using one vs. making your own plan.

Going the DIY route means tackling debt on your own — usually with either the avalanche method (paying highest interest first) or the snowball method (paying smallest balance first). Balance transfer cards can be amazing tools too, if you can qualify.

A debt management plan is a more structured program where the counselor negotiates with your creditors on your behalf. You make one monthly payment to the counseling agency, and they distribute it to each creditor. In many cases, they’re able to get interest rates reduced — regardless of your credit score.

A DMP typically takes 36 to 60 months to complete. Typical fees include a setup fee of $50 or less and possible monthly fees in the $25 range, according to the NFCC.

There’s also a middle ground worth mentioning. If your debt is manageable and your credit score is decent, a balance transfer card with a 0% intro APR period could let you pay down your balance without accruing any new interest. It’s not a replacement for counseling — but it’s a tool worth knowing about.

If that route interests you, compare today’s top-rated 0% intro APR balance transfer cards here and see which ones might fit your situation.

How to find a legit nonprofit credit counselor

The simplest way is to go directly to the NFCC or MMI websites. Both organizations have directories of certified counselors, and both offer free initial consultations by phone or online.

A few things to look for when vetting any counselor:

• They should be accredited by the NFCC or the FCAA (Financial Counseling Association of America)
• The initial session should be free or very low cost
• They should be transparent about any fees before recommending a DMP
• They should give you options, not a single path forward

If a counselor is pushing you hard toward a specific product or service in the first five minutes of the call, that’s a red flag. A good nonprofit counselor will lay out your options and let you decide.

The bottom line

The hardest part of getting help with debt is usually just admitting you need it. My friend knows that better than anyone.

But picking up the phone and making that call doesn’t mean you’re committing to anything. It means you’re being smart enough to understand your options before deciding what to do next. That’s it.

Nonprofit credit counselors are trained, certified, and genuinely there to help — not to sell you something. The call is free, the advice is real, and the worst case is you hang up exactly where you started.

We’re firm believers in the Golden Rule, which is why editorial opinions are ours alone and have not been previously reviewed, approved, or endorsed by included advertisers.
Motley Fool Money does not cover all offers on the market. Editorial content from Motley Fool Money is separate from The Motley Fool editorial content and is created by a different analyst team.The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.